Is the fear of unintentionally going viral changing clubbing for Gen Z?

Freya Price A crowded group photograph taken in a nightclub or live music venue. Several people are closely gathered together and filling most of the frame. Two people are positioned in the foreground, standing cheek-to-cheek near the centre, while additional people stand behind them in rows extending into the background. On the left side of the image, a raised arm wearing a multicoloured beaded bracelet reaches upward and partially enters the frame. The room is packed with people, with only small glimpses of walls and fixtures visible. Bright pink and purple club lighting shines from the upper right corner and reflects across faces, hair and clothing throughout the crowd. The setting appears busy and energetic, with people standing shoulder to shoulder in a lively indoor nightlife environment.
Freya Price
Freya said she and her friends are "on the lookout" for cameras so they can avoid them

Student Freya Price will be on a night out with her friends, but she cannot truly relax.

The 21-year-old is "hyper aware" while in nightclubs - avoiding promoters' cameras and watching for strangers filming - fully aware that any embarrassing moments could end up as content.

Freya said feeling monitored had cheated her out of the carefree night life Millennials enjoyed growing up.

While, for previous generations, embarrassing moments may have been talked about or uploaded to a blurry Facebook album, now they can be filmed, shared and viewed by thousands within hours.

Neuroscientist and author Dean Burnett said more people were "more anxious about doing something which could be seen as embarrassing online".

Freya said she wished she could feel comfortable dancing, being silly and enjoying the moment, but the thought of seeing videos of herself was "quite a big worry".

The third year Cardiff University student said she and her friends had often been minding their own business when "all of a sudden there's a camera in your face" as club promoters try to capture content.

On top of that, the fear of being caught in someone's TikTok plays on her mind.

She said some of her friends had appeared on club Instagram pages a week later looking "plastered".

She described this as a background worry that leaves her "on edge".

Freya is also worried about Meta glasses, having seen videos on social media of women after nights out without them being aware, as it is hard to tell between them and typical glasses.

"I find it quite scary how easy it's becoming to film people and post them on social media without them even knowing there's a camera."

Freya said she liked the idea of a sticker being put over the camera, as clubs in Berlin have done.

Tracy Clayton, a Meta spokesman, told the BBC people should behave responsibly with any technology and the company had teams "dedicated to limiting and combating misuse, but as with any technology, the onus is ultimately on individual people to not actively exploit it".

Freya Price Freya is sat in a restaurant, she has long brown hair and is smiling at the camera. She is wearing an amber pendant. She is sat on an orange leather sofa and is there are plants behind it. Freya Price
Freya said she does not want to unintentionally become content for other people

"Usually, when you're drunk your inhibitions are lowered, you're not really thinking but then it's like, 'oh, there's a camera here'," she said.

"I see on social media the '90s babies saying 'Gen Z is unlucky, in my time there was no phone, the worst thing that would happen is your picture would end up in someone's Facebook dump'."

She said for her generation, a drunk night out where something goes wrong "could impact jobs in the future" as, if online checks brought up videos of "you being paralytically drunk, they might not want that image".

Feeling embarrassed is a natural human response, but social media has altered how big the audience watching the moment is, said Burnett.

The honorary research fellow at Cardiff University said he was not surprised that young people who grew up in an environment where your actions end up online have altered behaviour.

He believes social media can be positive as it helps people find a community, but "I don't think it's necessarily a good thing for everyone to have an audience".

"I do think that's become part of a lot of people's thinking, what are my followers going to think?"

Dan Coughtrey Dean is wearing glasses sits at a wooden desk with hands clasped together, facing the camera. He is wearing a black polo top and watch. He is bald. Behind him are floor-to-ceiling wooden bookshelves filled with books and framed documents, giving the room the appearance of a personal library or office.Dan Coughtrey
Dean Burnett says embarrassment is the awareness of other people observing you and "could find you lacking"

He said a lot more people were "more anxious about doing something which could be seen as embarrassing online" while, on the other end of the spectrum, there were those who "do extreme things for likes and clicks".

The 43-year-old said: "A lot of people my age and older say 'I'm lucky I didn't have social media when I was younger because I got up to embarrassing things', but they assume they would have done the exactly the same things if they were on social media."

Burnett said, psychologically, it is unlikely these people would behave as they did in their youth if they had social media where their actions could be preserved.

Embarrassment, he added, is an evolutionary feature unique to humans.

"People say it's shallow to want people to like you, but in the first humans it was literally a matter of life or death. If you weren't part of the tribe, you died."

Freya Price Six people stand closely together for a photo at the entrance of a music venue. The group is framed by gold-coloured doors and windows, with a bright green “FREE ENTRY” sign overhead and colourful lights visible inside.Freya Price
Freya and her friends have swapped club nights for pub nights

This year was 19-year-old Hafwen Davies' first year at Cardiff University and she said seeing people "taking videos on Snapchat and stuff of other people or taking photos of themselves" was a lot more obvious in the students' union.

As the youngest in her family, her siblings and cousins told her about their experience, making friends on the dance floor and the huge photo dumps on Facebook.

"When they're taking photos it's like they are taking them to remember something, rather than going out to take photos," she said.

Hafwen Davies A portrait photograph taken indoors in a dark entertainment venue. One person is positioned in the centre of the frame, facing the camera from slightly above waist height. The person has shoulder-length curly red hair and is wearing a white open-knit cardigan over a green-and-white top decorated with a leafy botanical pattern. Small facial piercings are visible on the nose and ears. The lighting is low, with purple and pink light cast across the ceiling and faintly visible in the background. Most of the background is dark, making the person stand out against the surroundings. Hafwen Davies
Hafwen said feels like she can dance and let loose in clubs like Kings

For Edward Gent, being filmed or photographed did not even cross his mind when he was started university four years ago.

The 23-year-old said there was now an "ambient awareness that anybody could be filming" when out clubbing and felt it could "subconsciously change your behaviour without you even realising it".

He has seen the classic early 2000s photo dumps on Facebook and thinks "people are romanticising the anonymity of it, as much as the aesthetic".

"I think those blurry photos were almost as like a symbol of like 'we were present, we weren't performing'. Nobody was curating their night as such, and I think there's like a real hunger for that now."

Kaptin Barrett Four people pose closely together for a photograph in a dimly lit indoor venue. One person stands in the foreground at the centre of the group, while three others gather behind and beside them. The image is tightly cropped around the group, with blue sports-style tops visible on two people in the background and dark clothing on others.Kaptin Barrett
Kaptin Barrett in 2004 with his rap group Potato Skinz, including Dregz, Ruffstylz and Evil C

Someone who has seen the dancefloor evolve is DJ Kaptin Barrett, 49, who has been getting people out of their seats across the UK since 1999.

He said people still dance at his nights, but he has noticed from events he has attended that club vibes have changed since his 20s.

"In terms of people just really letting loose on the dance floor, you don't see it as much, it does happen, but people are a lot more self conscious," he said.

"The attention span as well, it's hard for people not to stare at their phone every five minutes."

Konrad Marciak A person wearing a baseball cap and a dark sweatshirt stands behind professional DJ equipment, with one hand on the controls. A microphone on a stand sits to the right, and the scene is lit by bright white and blue-tinted stage lighting against a simple backdrop.Konrad Marciak
Kaptin Barrett says it was "frustrating" in the early 2010s when people started getting absorbed in their phones and dancing decreased

He said raves and free parties still happen and "there is still a generation of youngsters who don't care, they actively are pushing away from that".

"If you go to a more mainstream, big name DJ, it's really hard to just lose yourself in dance because everyone's on their phones and everyone's filming the DJ, it's the same with a lot of concerts as well.

"The mystique of the club is gone. It's just somewhere where you go and either you go to dance or you go to be seen."

Certainly for Freya, clubs have lost their appeal and she and her friends are choosing pubs instead.

"I think it's a lot more social because you can actually hear each other, no-one's on their phone.

"At the pub, you're more likely to like engage in conversation and not worry about taking pictures on your phone or video your friend being silly."