Social media ban disappoints children's commission

The UK government's ban on social media for under-16s is "disappointing" and will not protect children from online harm, according to the Office of the Children's Commissioner for Jersey (OCCJ).

It said the ban announced by Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer on Monday was "a disappointing move that will neither keep children safe from potential online harms nor support their rights".

The commissioner is seeking clarity to find out the impact of the UK ban on children in Jersey.

The OCCJ said it was "neither the right, most effective, or only way of keeping children safe online and protecting their rights" and said it "diverts responsibility away" from social media companies.

It said companies "should be ensuring that their platforms are safe by design and creating appropriate spaces for children's engagement".

In his speech, Sir Keir said social media was making children unhappy, making it easier for bullies to abuse children, and was "designed to be addictive".

A ban would give children more time, security, and more freedom to grow up - as well as more opportunities, he added.

Jersey's previous government, led by Lyndon Farnham had expressed its support in principle for similar restrictions in Jersey.

The Office of the Children's Commissioner is an independent human rights organisation focused on the promotion and protection of children's rights in Jersey, and is wholly funded by the States.

Islander Magdalena Ford said the ban "will not solve the deeper problem" of "how many young people see themselves within a culture of constant comparison, unrealistic expectations, and endless pressure to be liked, followed, and approved of".

Other people said they backed the ban, with Donna Heads commenting: "It is a difficult one but if it helps to protect young children then yes."

In a statement on Monday, Jersey's Chief Minister Lyndon Farnham said: "Ministers have previously acknowledged public concern about the impact of smartphones and social media on children, supporting in principle measures to restrict their use by under-16s.

"Following its formation later this month, the new Council of Ministers will be asked to consider steps to strengthen safeguards and better protect children and young people from online harm.

"As part of this work, the Law Commission has been tasked with reviewing Jersey's existing legislation to identify any gaps and bring forward recommendations for reform."

Follow BBC Jersey on X and Facebook. Send your story ideas to channel.islands@bbc.co.uk.