Sutton have a corner in the second of two minutes of additional time at the end of the first period of extra time.
Shrewsbury clear their lines and a huge misunderstanding almost sees substitute Tommy McDermott go in one-on-one 40 yards from goal but Sutton keeper Jack Sims comes out well to slide at McDermott's feet, keeping the ball in the process.
A bit of argy bargy including Shrewsbury substitute Tommy McDermott, who falls to the ground, but the referee is not interested in taking any further matters having already sent off two players today.
Get Involvedpublished at 19:27 GMT 6 December 2025
19:27 GMT 6 December 2025
Use the 'Get Involved' button
Absolute howler - what a bad mistake by Sutton United. The defender is now left with egg on his face. Sutton United have really shot themselves in the foot here.
That has put a pin in the atmosphere at Sutton, which had been bouncing until around 10 minutes ago.
Sutton fans will be wondering with a man advantage, and a goal advantage going into additional time, how have they found themselves in their current situation.
Only two of the Chesterfield starting line-up from the 5-1 loss to Doncaster in the EFL Trophy on Tuesday night are in the side from the beginning this evening - skipper Chey Dunkley and Liam Mandeville.
Spireites boss Paul Cook makes just one change from their 2-1 loss to Swindon in League Two last Saturday as Ryan Stirk replaces the experienced midfielder John Fleck, who drops to bench.
Similarly, Doncaster make 10 alterations from the victory over Chesterfield in midweek, but are effectively unchanged from the side that beat Peterborough 2-1 in League One last weekend.
Can Chesterfield cause another upset?published at 19:24 GMT 6 December 2025
19:24 GMT 6 December 2025
Chesterfield v Doncaster (19:30 GMT)
Amid plenty of drama at Gander Green Lane, we've got another tie coming up shortly.
Four League One sides have already suffered upsets at the hands of League Two opposition in the FA Cup second round.
That will surely give Chesterfield reason for belief against Doncaster this evening after they also overcame League One high-fliers Stevenage 1-0 in the previous round.
Meanwhile, Doncaster, who are 16 league places above Chesterfield, edged past Crewe 2-1 in their first-round clash.
These two sides met in the EFL Trophy just four days ago and Rovers ran out comfortable winners, beating the Spireites 5-1.
But they both line up with very different teams this evening, so that's unlikely to be much of a barometer for this game. Team news on the way...
GOAL: Sutton 1-2 Shrewsburypublished at 19:20 GMT 6 December 2025
19:20 GMT 6 December 2025
John Marquis (92 mins)
Image source, Getty Images
Oh, what a gift for Shrewsbury!
Huge blow for Sutton who have been made to pay for trying to play the ball out from the back.
Their goalscorer Kai Jennings plays a dreadful square ball with his goalkeeper out of his goal and veteran striker John Marquis has the simplest of tasks of passing the ball into an unguarded net.
Perfect start to extra time for the League Two side.
Until Ismeal Kabia's stunning equaliser, it looked like Kai Jennings' goal direct from a corner was going to be enough for National League Sutton United to knock out Shrewsbury Town of League Two.
You can get a feel for how Will Brook was beaten by Jennings from the series of pictures below as we await extra time.