'Goodwin's time should be up'

We asked for your thoughts after Dundee United ended their season with a 1-1 draw against St Mirren.

Here's what some of you had to say:

George: Drifted through the last few games and finished seventh, not good enough. Jim Goowin says he knows what went wrong but also says he is happy up front? What! With strikers who can't hit the net on a regular basis. There are problems all over and we are about to lose some of the better players I think. Another rebuild needed Jim, starting with a reliable goalkeeper and dominant centre half. If he can find a twenty goal a season striker as well we'll be top six next season. Be brave Jim and good luck.

Tam: Outplayed for the fourth game in a row to end a desperately poor season. It's not just finishing in the bottom six, it's the dreadful football we endure watching the manager's 3-4-3 formation which rarely works. Add to that young goalkeeper Ruairidh Adams once again not given a chance, whereas perpetual liability Keresztes is picked yet again, Goodwin must be blind to all his defensive blunders repeatedly costing us goals this season.

Eddie: Goodwin's time should be up. Really bored of his tactics and hopeless team selections. He never sets his team up to win, 15 draws speaks for itself.

Frank: I'm all for giving managers/head coaches time but when you look at United's squad and consider who has improved under Jim Goodwin? In my opinion not one player.