'Wrong call' or 'absolutely right'? Your views on Townsend's new dealpublished at 15:25 BST 3 September 2025

We asked for your thoughts after Gregor Townsend signed a contract extension to stay as Scotland head coach until 2027.
Here's what you had to say:
Gus: Should have been sacked after the Japan World Cup - what a shambles that was. Had plenty of chances, he's not good at man management with a decent group of players.
Bill: A potential disaster for Scottish rugby. Flaky as a player and the same as a coach. The Autumn Tests will see Townsend fail yet again to properly utilise the best squad Scotland have had in years.
Stewart: It's absolutely the wrong call. The team is stagnating and Townsend's erratic team selection is a constant source of frustration. He should have gone after Japan and hasn't done enough to merit the previous contract never mind this. The SRU at its best.
Ali: I'm not surprised but I am frustrated. Imagine overseeing two dismal World Cups and then being given a shot at another. I don't think any other country in world rugby would do this. It might be understandable if we'd won a couple of Six Nations titles in the interim but we've not even come close. Another two years of, at best, mediocrity. I hope I am proven wrong.
Doug: I like Gregor and he's done pretty well with the squad inherited, but our tournament results have stagnated. I don't know if we have unrealistic expectations given our lack of player pool but I think a change would have been good to give another coach a chance. It seems like keeping Gregor was the easy option.
Mark: I see no need for change purely based on longevity. I've been to more Scotland Rugby games under Townsend's tenure than I had done in the previous 15 years. Why? Attractive, attacking brand of rugby to watch supported by the highest win-loss ratio of any Scotland head coach. Townsend himself comes across as progressive, adaptable and seems to be well regarded by the players including Finn Russell. While we might not win the World Cup isn't it great to be hugely competitive again after so many barren years? For all the Townsend bashers out there, be careful what you wish for!
George: Absolutely the right decision. Who else is available who matches his calibre? His flair is apparent in the squad's plays, backed by the power and strengths brought in by his backroom team - defence coach, strength and conditioning coaches etc.




















