Nottingham Forest

We asked for your thoughts after Sunday's Premier League game between Manchester United and Nottingham Forest.

Here are some of your comments:

Man Utd fans

Eric: Great performance from United. Forget the contentious handball decision - they were well-deserved winners after hitting the post twice, numerous other missed chances and a fair share of contentious decisions against them throughout this season. Some 29 shots at goal and Forest's keeper did well - and fair play to them as they added to a very entertaining "dead rubber", as Chris Sutton put it.

Mark: A really enjoyable game where we really should have scored more but a shoutout to Forest for making a good effort. We really need to tighten the defence up, especially at full-back, where we aren't good enough. Replacing Casemiro will be pivotal so it will be interesting to see who's brought in. Onwards and upwards then - I hope we can win something next season and push on from there.

Andrew: I thought this was a good performance overall, albeit definitely lucky with the second goal. Forest have been a solid side of late so it's a good result. It's so obvious that the focus needs to be on the Casemiro replacement. Look at Gibbs-White and Anderson - they'd transform United! Amad was wasteful and poor again! The defence was awesome! I hope we make signings early, not after the World Cup!

Christine: It was a very open game, especially in the second half and Bruno could have had five assists. Shaw scoring gave the game some impetus, and United actually pressed forward, with Mbeumo and Cunha scoring. The defence was comfortable but could have been tighter with the two Forest goals. Coming third in the Premier League has to be Manchester United's best season in years. From the depths of despair, achieving top three behind Manchester City and Arsenal is fantastic and United need to spend well in the summer with personalities that will fight for the club.

Nottingham Forest fans

Kris: A great display from a tired and depleted Forest side, away at a rejuvenated Manchester United. Such a pity it was largely settled by a very dubious refereeing decision. A lot of talk will turn to where Anderson 'ends up' next season, but I don't see this United team and manager attracting a player of his calibre.

John: A terrific display from every player. We deserved at least a draw but it wasn't to be and we all know why. Thank goodness we didn't need the points to stay in the Premier League. A great game spoiled only by the referee. VAR was supposed to prevent that.

Jason: Forest played well, best in a while, shame about the handball incident, but the referee made a wrong call. He clearly handled the ball.

Jon: Excellent performance from Forest. Morgan Gibbs-White and Elliot Anderson are demonstrating why they must both go to the World Cup. As for the handball, a terrible decision that could cost the club £5m based on where we finish in the table. Another VAR-trocity!

If there is one thing in the modern game that is guaranteed to confuse it is the handball law.

And at Old Trafford on Sunday we were presented with the latest example of a decision which has left supporters scratching their heads.

The ball hit the arm of Bryan Mbeumo, who saw his shot blocked before it ran to Matheus Cunha to score Manchester United's second goal in their 3-2 win over Nottingham Forest.

United's celebrations were muted as Forest's players complained to referee Michael Salisbury. Everyone seemed to expect that the goal would be ruled out.

Former Forest defender Brian Laws questioned on BBC Radio Nottingham: "What is a handball offence? Quite clearly - both of his arms are out and it's touched his body and arm. That dropped the ball to his side and from which he took a shot.

"That means he gained an advantage from it and it's an offence.

"I'm scratching my head and wondering if it's because he didn't score and it landed somewhere else for someone else to score, but that initial part is handball without a doubt."

Nottingham Forest boss Vitor Pereira told BBC Radio Nottingham: "It was a decision that decided the game.

"When I looked at the image, I was completely convinced that they would cancel out the goal. In this moment, we don't know the rules and we need to go to school to learn again because they've changed the rules.

"I think we need to have a meeting with everybody to understand when it is a handball or not."

Pundits Dion Dublin and Mark Schwarzer join host Gabby Logan to bring you the action and talking points from Friday's and Sunday's Premier League fixtures.

Watch on BBC iPlayer here

And listen back to full match commentaries on BBC Sounds:

• Leeds 1-0 Burnley

• Brentford 2-2 Crystal Palace

• Newcastle 3-1 West Ham

Simon Stone
Chief football news reporter

Image source, Getty Images

Elliot Anderson is Manchester United's number one midfield target to replace Casemiro this summer.

United know that Manchester City, among plenty of others, are also keen - and they are also unwilling to pay £120m for the England international.

However, as auditions go, this was a pretty good one.

Unlike another midfield option Carlos Baleba, who failed to make any impression when he played at Old Trafford for Brighton earlier this season, Anderson shone.

His covering play was efficient, but he also excelled in making the kind of driving runs out of midfield that Casemiro, for all his attributes, can no longer do. Plus his cross for Morato's equaliser was perfect.

Clearly, Nottingham Forest have a desire to drive the price up as high as possible, as they look at a rebuild after dicing too close to relegation for owner Evangelos Marinakis' liking.

While Anderson's exit appears certain, the future of Morgan Gibbs-White is also the subject of intense debate.

Gibbs-White seemed certain to join Tottenham last summer, but instead signed a new long-term deal to remain at the City Ground.

His importance to the side cannot be understated, and his absence from the second leg of the Europa League semi-final with Aston Villa was a significant factor in Forest's eventual defeat.

Wearing a face mask to protect the massive scarring on his face, Gibbs-White ghosted into space inside the penalty area midway through the first half and was only denied by Senne Lammens' feet.

When he did something similar in the second half, his first-time finish found the bottom corner.

So Forest will be reluctant to lose that game intelligence in the same summer as Anderson's industry.

Nottingham Forest boss Vitor Pereira has been speaking to BBC Match of the Day following the defeat at Old Trafford: "A crazy game, with transitions and counter-attacks. We played the last few minutes with heart and ambition but we lost our balance and organisation, and in the end this is a dangerous team on the counter-attack. They break intentionally and stay with three or four players for counter-attack, and this is a moment we need to control but we didn't and we tried to score.

"The only thing that was a pity, in my opinion, is that the game was decided by a decision. I don't agree with it. I looked at the image and I stayed very calm, but in the end I think we need to have a meeting together to understand when it is a handball, when it is a block and when it is a block in the box.

"At the moment, we don't know what is possible or not - and a lot of the time we don't understand the decisions, but I must accept it."

On character of his players: "Even if I want to keep them organised, they want to score and they will try everything not in an organised way. But I'm proud of my players and the supporters. We keep going with our work to try to win the next game. This is a special group.

"They have character and quality. When they try everything to get points from each game, we are in a position that we can do this because we are not in relegation battle. We wanted to win the game, but in the end this result wasn't possible."

Morgan Gibbs-White has also been talking to Sky Sports: "It was promising. The first half wasn't good enough, we were too slow, but second half we came out fighting, we showed character and desire. We kept fighting and we didn't give up."

On the handball decision: "No matter what I say, it's not going to change the outcome. From the angle I was standing at, it looked like he caught the ball. Whether he scores or not, for me it was still a handball.

"I asked him [the referee] after and he said if [Bryan] Mbeumo scores, it is not a goal. But because [Matheus] Cunha scored, it is a goal - that didn't make sense to me. He allowed the action to carry on when it should have got blown. I'm proud of the boys for the second half, we need to keep building and carrying on."

On whether the handball rules should be looked at: "We need to have clear rules. There is a lot of controversy around it this season. It is not clear to anyone. I don't think anyone understands the rulings on it."

Did you know?

• Nottingham Forest have lost nine of their past 11 Premier League away games against Manchester City and Manchester United, conceding two or more goals in each of those matches.

• Morgan Gibbs-White's goal was the 1000th goal scored in the Premier League this season. Since the start of March, no player has more goal involvements in the competition than the 26-year-old (10).

Various pundits have been discussing on-field referee Michael Salisbury's decision to award Manchester United's second goal against Nottingham Forest, despite an apparent handball by the Red Devils' Bryan Mbeumo in the build-up.

Former Premier League assistant referee Darren Cann told Final Score: "You can clearly see the ball comes off Mbeumo's arm prior to going to [Matheus] Cunha. For me, it is a penalisable handball.

"Mbeumo does control the ball and, while he is not the scorer himself, football's expectation is for a goal like that to be disallowed as opposed to being given.

"The law states that usually if it is the scorer who has accidentally or deliberately handled the ball before putting the ball in the back of the net, it will be disallowed.

"Football's expectation is that the handball outweighs any possible deflection off Mbeumo's hip.

"It is a good intervention from the VAR. I would've recommended a review myself, had I been the VAR. I do think that while it is commendable the referee sticks with their decision, which we don't see very often, this is only the fourth time it has happened. But I feel the correct decision is to disallow the goal for a handball.

"It is a decision that will split people. I can see both sides of the argument but we've had so many talks recently about needing to go back to deliberate handball. If it's unequivocally a handball, then we disallow. If the handball is accidental or if the arm is in an unnatural position, and we have all these clauses in the law, then it gets a bit complicated - so I would advocate for a return to just deliberate handball."

Former Manchester City defender Micah Richards said on Sky Sports: "It is a handball. It is as simple as that. The referee has gone to the screen and made a decision but, if you look at it, it is clear as day."

Former Manchester United midfielder Roy Keane added: "We are confused here, especially because the referee was asked to go to the screen and then still gave it.

"All of us ex-footballers will all be saying the same thing - handball. I don't think anyone would've complained about it. We were all scratching our heads when it was allowed."

Whether you were at the game or following from elsewhere, we want to know what you learned.

Have your say on Man Utd's performance

What did you make of Nottingham Forest's display?

Come back on Monday for a selection of your replies

Casemiro returns for his farewell appearance at Old Trafford.

The veteran Brazilian midfielder is one of three changes to the Manchester United starting line-up from the team that drew at Sunderland last week.

Diogo Dalot returns at right-back and Bryan Mbeumo is recalled. Mason Mount, Noussair Mazraoui and Joshua Zirkzee drop to the bench.

Manchester United XI: Lammens, Dalot, Maguire, Martinez, Shaw, Casemiro, Mainoo, Amad, Bruno Fernandes, Cunha, Mbeumo

Substitutes: Bayindir, Mazraoui, Mount, Zirkzee, Malacia, Dorgu, Yoro, Ugarte, Heaven

Morgan Gibbs-White returns for the visitors after his nasty facial injury. Chris Wood is back at centre-forward for the visitors, who also recall Omari Hutchinson to the starting line-up.

Ibrahim Sangare is named on the bench for Nottingham Forest, who have eased clear of relegation trouble.

Nottingham Forest XI: Sels, Milenkovic, Morato, Williams, Dominguez, Anderson, Netz, Hutchinson, Gibbs-White, Igor Jesus, Wood

Substitutes: Victor, Ortega, Sangare, Awoniyi, Yates, Cunha, McAtee, Bakwa, Abbott

There are six games in the Premier League on Sunday and BBC Sport will bring you every moment.

• Manchester United v Nottingham Forest (12:30)

• Brentford v Crystal Palace - listen on BBC Radio 5 Sports Extra

• Everton v Sunderland

• Leeds v Brighton - listen on BBC Radio 5 Live

• Wolves v Fulham

• Newcastle v West Ham (17:30) - listen on BBC Radio 5 Live

Kick-offs 15:00 unless stated

Follow all of the action and reaction here

You can also listen to today's 5 Live Premier League commentaries on most smart speakers. Just say "ask BBC Sounds to play Leeds v Brighton" or "ask BBC Sounds to play Newcastle v West Ham", for instance.

Find out more about how to listen to Premier League football on BBC Sounds

Tom McCoy
BBC Sport journalist

BBC Sport examines some of the key themes before Sunday's match (12:30 GMT) between Manchester United and Nottingham Forest, which is set to be Casemiro's final home appearance for the Red Devils.

Manchester United sealed Champions League qualification with victory over Liverpool in their previous home match – and securing a return to Europe's top competition appears increasingly likely to earn head coach Michael Carrick the job on a permanent basis.

He was this week named on a six-man shortlist for the Premier League's Manager of the Season award. He has reportedly now also been endorsed by senior figures within the Old Trafford hierarchy.

Chief executive Omar Berrada and director of football Jason Wilcox are expected to recommend to co-owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe that the former Middlesbrough boss is offered a new contract.

Casemiro's Old Trafford farewell

United have lost their final home league game just once in the past 18 seasons and will be keen to ensure veteran midfielder Casemiro bows out on a high in his final home appearance.

The Brazilian, 34, has played a pivotal role for United this season, starting 32 of 36 top-flight fixtures and scoring a career-best nine league goals.

While his departure will free up a sizeable chunk of the club's wage budget to invest in more long-term options, replacing the former Real Madrid star won't be easy.

United have won 54.7% of the matches he has featured in since arriving in 2022, compared to just 38% when he has been absent. They have also scored more goals per game, and conceded fewer, when he has been involved.

In-form Forest savour safety

Elliot Anderson's late goal against his former club Newcastle last weekend earned Nottingham Forest a draw which ultimately proved enough to guarantee survival.

West Ham's defeat by Arsenal a few hours later confirmed they were mathematically assured of their top-flight status with two games remaining.

Vitor Pereira, Forest's fourth head coach of the season, joked on Thursday that he is now able to "sleep properly" but also said the club needs to understand "the things we cannot do again" to reach "the next level".

Pereira has effectively rallied his side during the final two months of the season, with Forest finding consistency when they needed it most to pull clear of the relegation battle.

They are unbeaten in eight league games, the third longest current undefeated run in the top flight – form bettered by only Bournemouth and Manchester City.

The last time Forest enjoyed a longer undefeated streak in a single Premier League campaign was 31 years ago.

This is a proper dead rubber, with Nottingham Forest safe now, and Manchester United guaranteed a Champions League spot.

That makes it harder to call but United boss Michael Carrick will still be desperate for a strong end of the season and retain the feel-good factor at Old Trafford.

Nottingham Forest won't want to let their season just peter out, either, but the pressure is off them now and, because of that, I am backing United here - this game is more important to them than it is to Forest.

Sutton's prediction: 2-0

Read the full predictions and have your say here

Image source, Getty Images

A new episode of the Shut Up And Show More Football podcast with BBC Radio Nottingham's David Jackson and Colin Fray is now available to listen to and download on BBC Sounds.

The panel chat in-depth after Forest's Premier League survival was confirmed with two games yet to play.

"Two games now for Forest fans to actually enjoy," said Fray.

"We make it probably only the second and third games since Forest got back into the Premier League with absolutely nothing riding on it.

"It's come after a remarkable turnaround. Not immediate under Vitor Pereira - he lost a couple of early games - but 16 points from the last eight in the Premier League is an extraordinary record.

"Two points across that many games in the Premier League for a side that was really struggling, and heading down rather than up, is an incredible turnaround."

Listen below or on BBC Sounds here - and don't forget to subscribe to get each episode into your My Sounds feed.

Explore all Nottingham Forest content on BBC Sounds

Grace Wheeler
BBC Sport

Nottingham Forest boss Vitor Pereira has been speaking to the media before Sunday's Premier League game against Manchester United at Old Trafford (kick-off 12:30 BST).

Here are the key lines from his news conference:

• Pereira provided an update on midfielder Morgan Gibbs-White after he suffered a facial injury last week: "He started today [Thursday], to work with the team. Let's see, with a mask. You know, it's strange when we use the mask, but in the end I spoke with him, said 'I'm okay, I'm okay with the mask, no problem'. We'll see if he's ready of his conditions for the next game."

• On other team news, he added: "Murillo out, [Ola] Aina out, but in this moment I think Dan Ndoye. Morgan [Gibbs-White] and Ibrahim Sangare will be on the training tomorrow."

• Asked about reports that Forest are in talks with Neco Williams about a new deal at the club: "I don't know. But he's another player that deserves everything. He's consistent. I know what I can expect from him every game. He's a player that deserves everything. I think we play very consistent since the time that we are working together. He has been very consistent with quality defending and attacking, he is a very good player."

• Pereira spoke about the potential for Morgan Gibbs-White to win Premier League Player of the season: "He deserved everything from the top player. As I said before, the top player deserves everything that life gives to him or football gives to him because the fighter has a lot of talent, is a leader, and he deserves, in my opinion, everything."

• On if the midfielder will make it into the England World Cup squad: "I think he wants to prove himself every time, wants to get every chance to prove himself and to prove that he has the quality and the talent to be there."

Follow all of Thursday's Premier League news conferences and the rest of the day's football news

Got a question about Forest? Get in touch here and we'll seek answers from our experts

Sami Mokbel
Senior football correspondent

Image source, Getty Images

Nottingham Forest have opened talks with Neco Williams over a new contract extension, amid growing Premier League interest in the full-back.

The 25-year-old has been a key player for Forest this season, playing 51 times for the club so far and also wearing the captains armband recently, with his performances attracting admiration from rival teams.

The Wales international still has three years to run on his current deal, which he signed last summer, but it is understood discussions over an improved contact are underway.

The talks come amid a backdrop of significant interest in the left-back from a number of Premier League clubs before the summer transfer window.

Newcastle, Aston Villa, Manchester United and Everton are all understood to have made discreet enquiries to understand Williams' situation heading into the summer.

But Forest are determined to keep the former Liverpool defender at the City Ground, and hope the offer of a new deal can end any uncertainty over his future.

Williams joined Forest in July 2022 for a fee of £12m and has since gone on to make over 150 appearances for the club.

Manchester United are ready to make a formal move for Nottingham Forest's England midfielder Elliot Anderson, 23. (Give Me Sport), external

Want more transfer stories? Read Thursday's full gossip column

Follow the gossip column on BBC Sport

Former Premier League assistant referee Darren Cann has outlined his idea to improve how corners are officiated in future.

In the aftermath of weekend controversy over players grappling in the penalty area, he has told BBC Sport a rule whereby attacking players cannot enter the six-yard box until a corner has been taken would be his preference.

Ex-Premier League defender Nedum Onuoha backed the idea and thinks it will add "creativity" to corner kicks and the move would force "people to think in a different way".

You can watch a clip of the debate above, with Onuoha stating: "Twenty players standing in the six-yard box, you have to ask yourself, is that what you want to see? And is that the best version of the game?"

• Listen to the show in full on BBC Sounds

• Watch the show in full on iPlayer

Despite helping Nottingham Forest avoid relegation, manager Vitor Pereira could be replaced by Fulham boss Marco Silva this summer. (Teamtalk), external

Want more transfer stories? Read Wednesday's full gossip column

Follow the gossip column on BBC Sport

Image source, Getty Images

BBC Radio Nottingham's Colin Fray believes Vitor Pereira has carried out a "terrific turnaround" at Nottingham Forest since arriving in February, having ensured Premier League safety and guided the club to a Europa League semi-final.

So we asked you to rate his time at the club so far and for your thoughts on safety being secured.

Here are some of your replies:

Tina: It feels a bit like a miracle. He has moulded a disjointed group of lads into a team again. I wasn't sure what to expect, but I respect to him for doing it and the team for embracing it. We've had fight, fire and an attitude that I was worried had abandoned us. Good job, boss!

Ian: What he has done is truly remarkable but, looking at the stats, it is clear we've massively over-performed and we've had more than our slice of luck. What has happened over last eight games is not sustainable. Ultimately, things will settle back to a true reflection of where we are, which unfortunately is a bottom-third-of-the-league side. Unless we hit lucky with recruitment, I can see our owner getting another manager in after a poor start to next season.

Edward: For the first time this season the players truly responded to a head coach. Maybe it was a combination of Vitor's approach and a realisation that the players couldn't be seen to not cooperate with another head coach. With the number and quality of managerial free agents available this summer, it would be perfectly in character for Evangelos Marinakis to ditch him for a bigger name. If he does stay, I hope everyone is on the same page regarding recruitment and business is done early. All of this season's failures stemmed from the club's fractious pre-season; in stark contrast to the harmonious pre-season of 2024-25.

TJ: Vitor Pereira is exactly what Forest need. For us, it is more about connection with the manager than the playing style - and luckily he has brought both. This is the best football we have played for a few years. However, I still think he might get the chop this summer and I'm fearful for next season without Elliot Anderson and Morgan Gibbs-White!

Sean: When Vitor was appointed, my exact reaction was that - as our fourth manager of the season - it didn't matter what he'd bring because we'd still go down. Turmoil behind-the-scenes, a disjointed squad and an unhappy fanbase was too much to overcome, in my opinion. However, sitting safe in the Premier League for our fourth season in a row, I'm glad to be wrong. He has turned it around and done it in style. We've been competitive against the likes of Man City and Liverpool, and we were scoring for fun against Burnley and Sunderland. Plus we got that victory against Chelsea with our misfiring B-team. I'm tipping us for relegation again next season, if only to be proven drastically wrong again! In Vitor we trust.

Pat Riddell
Fan writer

Image source, Getty Images

In a week in which Nottingham Forest achieved one of their two goals this season - and narrowly missed out on the other - thoughts now turn to the future.

Securing Premier League survival with two games to go means planning can begin for next season. Sadly, it's not planning for a place in the Champions League but, after two seasons of almost qualifying, it seems realistic to aim high.

But what does planning look like? Vitor Pereira only has until next summer on his contract and without Champions League football it's likely that we'll lose one or two star players.

It's hard to see a world where we keep Elliot Anderson after the World Cup, but if he's being talked about as the most expensive English Premier League player... well, we should have some money to strengthen.

But, if anything, we need stability this summer - last summer's chaos followed by the ongoing turmoil of this season means we need to get it right. Very few of the new arrivals in 2026, and during the January transfer window, hit the ground running and ultimately - on top of four managers - that almost got us relegated.

Even without European competition, there are still 38 Premier League games and two cup competitions to battle for so, for any kind of consistency, we need a squad ready to deal with injuries, suspensions and tactical changes.

The work begins now for the club to be ready for pre-season in July.

There are still two games left and a World Cup in between, but absolute clarity is needed for next season to avoid the mess we embraced this campaign.

Find more from Pat Riddell at The Famous Club, external

Colin Fray
BBC Radio Nottingham reporter

Image source, Getty Images

It has been a terrific turnaround by Nottingham Forest in the backend of this season.

They were in big trouble, but Vitor Pereira and his coaching staff have managed to get a disjointed squad turned around into a side that is now unbeaten in their last eight Premier League games.

In those eight games, they have taken 16 points. From the previous 28 games, they had taken 27 points. So they have gone from earning less than one point per game for the first 28 games to taking two points per game for the last eight games.

That shows the turnaround.

It needed to be such a turnaround as well because the likes of Tottenham, West Ham and Leeds have been winning matches down there as well. Forest have had to be that good to get to safety - and they did it with two games spare in the end.

They can relax at least now because they know they will be playing Premier League football next season, but I'm sure they will be aiming to finish the season with Pereira's unbeaten Premier League run intact.

Then it will be about rebuilding to make sure they aren't down at that end of the table against next season.

What Vitor Pereira has done is put smiles on faces. He has made the Forest dressing room a happy place again. They have always been a confident bunch, no matter the head coach, because they always felt they had enough in there but they needed some unification.

Pereira has certainly done that. I remember when he walked into the job, on his first day there he said: 'A smile can do magic' - and he has beamed his way through his tenure at Forest.

Do you think it is a job well done for Vitor Pereira? How would you rate his time at the club so far?

Let us know your thoughts here

Listen to the full post-match debrief on BBC Sounds

Listen to full commentary on every Nottingham Forest game, and In The Game every weeknight from 18:00, on BBC Radio Nottingham.

And subscribe to the Shut Up And Show More Football podcast on BBC Sounds.