'Whole club seems lost' - your viewspublished at 13:01 BST 1 September 2025

We asked for your thoughts after Aberdeen lost again in the Premiership, this time against newly-promoted Falkirk.
Here is what some of you had to say:
Doug: Five wins in more than 30 games doesn't feel like a 'project' on the right track. The cup win feelgood factor has evaporated in a glaring goal-free void. The rumoured sale of young Fletcher Boyd to Aston Villa is another example of proven talent being swapped for players hoping Aberdeen will help them rediscover their lost mojos. The whole club seems lost at the minute.
Bob: Replacing men with boys. There doesn't appear to be any ambition at Pittodrie. Relegation material for sure.
Colin: The midfield never manages to take control of a match. The defending is at times embarrassing. Attacks break down as soon as they near the penalty area. There is no movement to anticipate passes and open up defences. There is no striker worth the name. Jimmy Thelin's mumbled platitudes get more irritating every week. The results are dire. How long can we continue like this?
Allen: Even though he won the cup, Thelin is not up to the job. He is far too quiet. Nae goals, nae points and bottom of the league with little chance of improvement. The man has to go.
Dick: From assessment of the play against FCSB and Falkirk the outfield play and activity in the opposition box is more exciting than last year. The creation of quality opportunities and ability to convert them is still not there and this defence will continue to leak goals.
Malky: How long will it take before Thelin is scrutinised? Cup win aside, and of course I wouldn't trade it in for anything, the league record is abysmal. We are one of the most predictable teams in the league & never look like scoring.
























