Summary

Which laws would you change in football? Ask Chris Foy

  1. Choose now - Which of these laws would you most like to see changed?published at 13:48 GMT 11 November 2025

    Have your say at the top of this page

    As you might have noticed already, we have a poll going at the top of this page now.

    We've received plenty of ideas on reinventing football and have now identified four of the most talked about rule changes that you would like to see introduced in football and they are:

    • Clear ‘daylight’ offside - no more microscopic calls, attacker must be clearly ahead of the last defender
    • Return to the old handball rules - keep it simple and consistent
    • Stop the clock for every stoppage - no more time-wasting, full 60/90 minutes of action
    • Faster VAR decisions - streamline the process and keep the game flowing

    Get your choice in right now and tell us which change you would back...

  2. Make the goals bigger?published at 13:45 GMT 11 November 2025

    Goalkeeper Kjell Scherpen of Sturm Graz catches the ball during a Champions League game against RB LeipzigImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    At 6ft 9in, Kjell Scherpen set a record as the tallest goalkeeper to play in the Premier League when he was at Brighton

    In 1996, former Fifa president Sepp Blatter wanted to increase the size of football goals by 50cm in width and 25cm in height, but didn't have enough support.

    Is it time to look again?

    The size of the goals - 24ft wide and 8ft high – hasn't changed in 150 years.

    But the average height of people has increased in that time, which would suggest goalkeepers are now at an advantage.

    There are two sides to this, though.

    In 1875, footballs were made of hand-stitched leather, often weighed down by the rain. Today they are lightweight and made of synthetic leather and designed to aid movement through the air.

    Goalkeepers would argue that any advantage they have is only matched by the evolution of the ball and the athleticism of outfield players. Do attackers really need more goal to aim at?

    Make the goals bigger? Thumbs up for yes, down for no...

  3. get involved

    Get Involved - 'I just want consistency'published at 13:41 GMT 11 November 2025

    Click 'Get Involved' at the top of this page to have your say

    I just want consistency with refereeing decisions. Every week it seems there is a new controversial decision that has been made that seems to unite football fans, regardless of team involved, as we all know it can/probably will happen to us.

    Dave

  4. 'Fans in each country think their refs are the worst'published at 13:37 GMT 11 November 2025

    Dale Johnson
    Football issues correspondent

    Barcelona actionImage source, Getty Images

    My experience in covering the subject across the major leagues is that fans in each country all seem to think their referees are the worst.

    There are major systemic problems with officiating, how it is perceived, and how it has fallen behind in the professional game. All national associations are having to wrestle with this, and there's no magic wand to produce instant change.

  5. get involved

    Chris Foy Q&A on referee performancespublished at 13:32 GMT 11 November 2025

    Ask former Premier League referee Chris Foy your question - click Get Involved at the top of this page

    Virgil van DijkImage source, Getty Images

    Nolberto has asked: "Why in your opinion do English referees perform so poorly compared to their continental counterparts? How do we go about improving their image at major tournaments?"

    Here's what Chris said:

    "English referees are held in very high esteem outside of the UK. They regularly operate across many European competitions. If you consider that at the recent Club World Cup and the last World Cup, England provided two refereeing teams. Only a couple of countries compare with this.

    "It should also be borne in mind that as competitions are reaching a climax, English teams' participation will rule out further appearances from English refereeing teams.

    "One thing that I found really useful as a referee was to plan and prepare thoroughly for matches. This was not just physically but having an insight into how teams set up and an understanding what tactics they employ.

    "Being aware of any potential flash points from previous encounters was also important. This was a big part of my preparation and a really important part of my refereeing DNA."

  6. get involved

    Get Involved - 'Stop yellows for taking shirt off'published at 13:28 GMT 11 November 2025

    Click 'Get Involved' at the top of this page to have your say

    We should get rid of giving yellow cards to players who take their shirt off when celebrating a goal - why does this rule exist?

    George

    Stop booking player's for taking their shirts off. It's taking the joy out of out of the game.

    Dave

  7. 'Sin bins could stop dissent'published at 13:23 GMT 11 November 2025

    Ellen White
    Former England striker on BBC Radio 5 Live

    How many players can you have off at one time?

    I think that'd be great, and hopefully that will stop all the dissent for officials. Definitely agree.

  8. What was the '10-yard' rule?published at 13:19 GMT 11 November 2025

    The 10-yard rule, which moves play 10-yards towards the offending team's goal if players show dissent, that Chris was talking about was used in English football for four seasons before it was scrapped by Fifa in 2005.

    "It is a disappointing decision because while the law was not used a lot, it did have an impact on the behaviour of players," the then Premiership referees' chief Keith Hackett said.

    "The referees over here found it acted as a deterrent.

    "The problem, as I understand it, is the countries who do not have any familiarity with the concept couldn't get their heads around the process."

  9. get involved

    Chris Foy Q&A on dissent, sin bins and simulationpublished at 13:14 GMT 11 November 2025

    Ask former Premier League referee Chris Foy your question - click Get Involved at the top of this page

    Aston Villa v Bournemouth actionImage source, Getty Images

    Fooling the ref or shouting abuse towards them are both bookable offences but fans believe they aren't seeing it enough.

    Stephen wants to see immediate red cards for 'abusive language' while Jeff believes simulating a foul goes 'against the spirit of the game'

    But a lot of you are questioning the effectiveness of yellow cards altogether and whether offences such as these, should be punished with a rugby-style sin bin.

    Mick and Domenico think sin bins will give the advantage to the team who was 'sinned against' and Richard thinks it's unfair for players to be sent off for 'two minor infractions'.

    Here's what Chris said:

    "Dissent is a problem at many levels of football and when I was refereeing it was no different. If open acts of dissent are detected they should be dealt with.

    "The experiment of the 9.15 metre advancement was a good example of how we could reduce dissent.

    "I experienced and applied the 9.15 meter or as some say 10 yards advancement. This was used when a player showed dissent by word or action. You would caution the player and move the ball forwards. I really liked it but unfortunately it wasn’t adopted.

    "2019 saw the introduction of Sin Bins at grassroots football which is a great addition for dealing with open shows of dissent.

    "Referees cannot do it alone and everyone has a duty to protect the image of the game."

  10. get involved

    Get Involved - 'Bring in sin bins'published at 13:10 GMT 11 November 2025

    Click 'Get Involved' at the top of this page to have your say

    Change the red card rule - Too many players are sent off for two minor infractions that don’t deserve this penalty. Being sent off should be as a result of l dangerous / violent play not two minor fouls or sometimes less.

    Richard

    10 minutes sin bin for yellow cards like in rugby. Will punish cynical fouls more, diving and also talking back to referee.

    Julian

    Yellow cards do not affect the game that the offence occurred in so, sin bins .

    Mick

    Bring in an Ice hockey style sin bin. Say five mins for yellow, 20 mins second yellow. So that the advantage be given to team that was sinned against. Not to some random team in the future. Leave red cards as they are.

    Domenico

  11. get involved

    Get Involved - Dirty side of football: simulation and dissentpublished at 13:05 GMT 11 November 2025

    Click 'Get Involved' at the top of this page to have your say

    Why isn't dissent/arguing with the referee properly punished? Five+ players can swarm the ref and none of them get a yellow card!

    Stephen

    Swearing at the ref - Any abusive language = immediate red card and a four match ban

    Christopher

    Any attempt to simulate a foul would be an instant yellow card, but given when break in play, and monitored by VAR. Any holding or pulling of clothing to be a yellow card, again monitored by VAR. Both of these are against the spirit of the game.

    Jeff

    Implement cards for any kind of simulation. Too many players conning the ref trying to get advantage, in particular players going down holding face or head when never touched. Classic example was Gabriel holding his face for Sunderland's second goal when clearly no where near his face.

    Dave

  12. Diving 'should be a three-game ban'published at 13:00 GMT 11 November 2025

    Chris Sutton
    Former Premier League striker

    Oscar of Chelsea goes down in the area after seemingly making contact with goalkeeper Kelvin Davis of SouthamptonImage source, Getty Images

    I think all football fans are behind me with this - the players who dive, cheat and try and con the referees, when they do that, it should be a red card offence and not a yellow card offence. And it should be a three-game ban, a strong deterrent to stop them from doing it again. It infuriates the fans all across the country. Every week it's endless.

    I get that there are contentious decisions, but there are very obvious ones. And the obvious ones - Vinicius for Real Madrid last week in the Champions League. Real Madrid is one of the best teams in the world; Vinicius is one of the greatest players in the world. Just ban him.

    And it filters down to all levels. They see the pros do it, and they start doing it on Sunday mornings.

  13. get involved

    Get Involved - 'Need VAR for the honesty of the game'published at 12:54 GMT 11 November 2025

    Click 'Get Involved' at the top of this page to have your say

    Need VAR for the honesty of the game. Referees make human mistakes, plus some are not that good. They also don't have eyes in the back of their heads. However, VAR needs to be sped up as it can take too long to make a decision.

    Alison

  14. get involved

    Chris Foy Q&A on players surrounding the refereepublished at 12:47 GMT 11 November 2025

    Ask former Premier League referee Chris Foy your question - click Get Involved at the top of this page

    Referee surrounded by playersImage source, Getty Images

    Paul has asked: "Why is it that IFAB 'Only the Captain' rules on players surrounding referees are never really implemented? There are still hoards of players surrounding referees. Do you think referees will ever book players en masse to stop this at higher levels and prevent it at grassroots?"

    Here's what Chris said:

    "Captains only rule is new this season and it's optional to competitions. It is recommended that it be mandatory in the laws of the game by The Technical Panel at IFAB.

    "What you don’t see is that when teams surround match officials, these incidents are reported.

    "In relation to cautioning a number of players simultaneously, it wouldn’t be a good look. And is that what football expects or wants?"

  15. get involved

    Get Involved - 'VAR an unnecessary addition'published at 12:41 GMT 11 November 2025

    Click 'Get Involved' at the top of this page to have your say

    VAR, if something takes more than a minute, it’s not clear and obvious. Refs have a big enough on-field team, VAR is an unnecessary addition, and I would love to know the cost to clubs, and why they don't bin it?

    Jeff

    Get rid of VAR completely. We had 120-odd years of the old system when football was football. Now, it's a waste of time.

    Mike

  16. Should football introduce tactical timeouts?published at 12:36 GMT 11 November 2025

    Manager Marco Silva speaks with his Fulham players on the touchlineImage source, Getty Images

    For this, we turn to former Wales captain Ashley Williams.

    "I would give each team at least one timeout per half, and you can use that whenever you want," he said.

    "It might be before a corner, before a free-kick, if someone's injured. If the manager needs to get hold of their team and change something, I'd let them have a timeout like they do in other sports."

    Introduce tactical timeouts? Thumbs up for yes, down for no...

  17. get involved

    Get Involved - 'Change VAR to challenges like in tennis'published at 12:31 GMT 11 November 2025

    Click 'Get Involved' at the top of this page to have your say

    VAR only gets used via challenge cards given to the managers. If the decision goes in favour of the manager, the card is kept.

    Tom

    Change VAR to challenges like in tennis, give each team two or three challenges per game.

    Chris

  18. Daylight offside - 'I'd be very surprised if it ever happens'published at 12:27 GMT 11 November 2025

    Dale Johnson
    Football issues correspondent

    Linesman Adrian Holmes lifts his flag to signal for offsideImage source, Getty Images

    'Daylight offside' has been a topic of discussion ever since it was suggested by Arsene Wenger in 2020.

    It has not made it to full trials because there are serious doubts about its impact on the tactical approach to a game. Giving more advantage to the attacker doesn't necessarily mean more goals, it could lead to more defensive play. I'd be very surprised if this ever happens.

  19. get involved

    Get Involved - 'You can only be offside beyond the 18-yard line'published at 12:23 GMT 11 November 2025

    Click 'Get Involved' at the top of this page to have your say

    I would like the offside law changed, so you can only be offside beyond the 18-yard line. This would spread out the play.

    Chris

    Scrap offside completely. It’s a stupid rule. It takes forever on VAR, and half the time, people don’t accept the VAR decision anyway. Follow hockey’s lead and do away with it entirely. It makes for a much better game.

    Andy

  20. get involved

    Chris Foy Q&A on the offside rulepublished at 12:20 GMT 11 November 2025

    Ask former Premier League referee Chris Foy your question - click Get Involved at the top of this page

    Linesman flaggingImage source, Getty Images

    Despite VAR and semi-automated technology, the offside laws remain an issue for the followers of the game. .

    Sal wants clear 'daylight' between the attacker and the last defender when it comes to offside calls and Matt is concerned with the time it takes for the assistant referee to flag the offside.

    Here's what Chris said:

    "Assistant refereeing is an artform and they are encouraged to keep the flag down in clear attacking situations. But I do understand that sometimes it can be frustrating.

    "With semi-automated technology, I believe we have an accurate judgment of offside."