BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.

24 September 2014
South YorkshireSouth Yorkshire
GREEDY COW

BBC Homepage
»BBC Local
South Yorkshire
Things to do
People & Places
Nature
History
Religion & Ethics
Arts and Culture
BBC Introducing
TV & Radio

Sites near Sheffield

Bradford
Derby
Humberside
Leeds
Manchester
Nottingham

Related BBC Sites

England
 

Contact Us


July 2002
The Kelham Island Tavern
Greedy Cow
Greedy Cow: beer behind the bar!
A pub that tries to be traditional, and ends up a little contrived, says Mat. But Albert disagrees.
FACTS

The Kelham Island Tavern
62 Russell Street Sheffield S3

0114 272 9463

PRINT THIS PAGE
View a printable version of this page.
get in contact

2 moos (Mat)
4 moos (Albert)

Lurking just round the corner from the Fat Cat (you could easily throw a stone from the beer garden of one pub into the other) this pub is a recent addition to the hostelries of the area and seems to be an attempt to create a traditional atmosphere in a newly fitted out establishment.

The small taproom is just a little too small and due to the fact that it's the only room inside the pub it gets a little crowded at night when it's too cold to be out in the beer garden.

The range of beverages on offer here is a little bit more spartan and a good deal less organic than that of the Fat Cat across the road, but if you persevere you should find something to your liking.

The one thing that must be said is that this place tries just a little to hard to be a traditional old alehouse and ends up looking contrived.

Faded sepia photographs of old Sheffield scenes are one thing, but dried hops hanging from the celing and the like is another altogether when you consider that the place looks out onto a vacant lot paved with concrete in the red-light district.

There are actually advertisements for morris dancing on the walls in this place, you have been warned...

- Mat

Your views

sam
what an excellent beer garden, roll on summer!

Andy N.
Great pub,very friendly. Smashing range of beers(plenty of real ales always available) Very nicely decorated & mega popular at weekends.(get there early,you have been warned!) Food is sensibly priced too. Well Done!

Jarmo
I find the sandwiches, pork scratchings, crisps and a gallon just about fill me up

bocko
ooooooh that warsteiner is just the business

curly specky
i just love the easy rider it's ace

Mat
I'd rather they didn't get rid of the review as it's my opinion (to which I am entitled) and not that out of date. The comments that my review sparked present a different view of the pub in question and I welcome that as any review can sound one-sided. I have never taken the mickey out of English tradition and have seen and enjoyed many forms of folk-dancing in the vicinity of said pub. I simply try to write my review from the perspective of a young person rather than as a devotee of Real Ale (which I am) as when the latter write they tend to be hostile to any criticism of their favoured drinking dens even when fair and evenly expressed (i.e. my review of the Hilsborough Hotel).

Dave
This is an ace pub. Sorry your original writer/reviewer feels he needs to take the mickey out of english traditions. And since the review is badly out-of-date why not get rid of it and get someone else to bring it up-to-date?

Howard Thomas
An excellent pub good beer

dave
Fantastic Pub Best pub in Sheffield by far beer is spot on , you can see they really care about the beer ,great atmosphere,can you open one in crookes please(worth the taxi fair though)

Meaks
This excellent pub now has a large no smoking extension at the back, while still retaining an outside garden area and the traditional bar. The extension means that there is much more seating available but be warned - due to the increasing popularity of the place the pub still gets packed out at weekends. Great, mixed crowd and the excellent selection of ever changing beer is easily as good (if not better) than the other Real Ale pubs in the area. Won the 2004 CAMRA pub of the year award, and well deserved.

Dave Hulme
An excellent pub now a firm favourite with locals and newcomers alike.A wide range of beers suits all tastes and with good pub grub served daily at lunchtime it gets extremely busy. New addition is the non smoking to the rear which has been tastefully decorated in keeping with the original pub.It has also recently been voted as pub of year. What more can you say.

Michael J Hodgson
A comfortable, claean and friendly pub serving excellent beer at reasonable prices.

Bill
Everything I like. World class beer at around 1.50 a pint. Friendly and comfortable. Quiet enough for those alcohol-fuelled taproom philosophy sessions, not so quiet it makes you nervous. Excellent!

Albert Jackson writes:

4 moos

Situated within the Kelham Island Conservation Area and originally the White Hart dating back to the 1880's it was refurbished and re-opened in 2002 after being closed for several years.

Now a comfortable and friendly one roomed pub with kitchen and beer garden it boasts up to 8 real ales from Independent Breweries with prices starting at £1.38 per pint, plus draft and bottled Belgian Biers.

It is fast becoming a favourite haunt of the Kelham Island Trail - boasting a Folk Night every Sunday.

Add your comments
Have you been to this watering hole? Add your comments to this review! Fill in the form below and we'll pop them on this page!

What's your name?

Tell us what you thought about this review:

Thanks for your comments. Please be aware that comments take a day or so to appear.
Disclaimer: The BBC may edit your comments and cannot guarantee that all e-mails will be published.

line
Top | Greedy Cow Index | Home

Also in Greedy Cow
Greedy Cow goes to market!

Greedy goes ghost hunting...

South Yorkshire beer tasting!

A trip inside Henderson's

Greedy Cow's FAQs

Meet the real Greedy Cows!

Also in Greedy Cow
Grub reviews A-Z

Grub reviews by cuisine

Pub and bar reviews A-Z

Pub and bar reviews by area

The Bull's Breakfasts

Write a Greedy Cow review
Going Out Fun on a shoestring Contact Us
BBC South Yorkshire
54 Shoreham Street
Sheffield
S1 4RS
(+44) (0)114 273 1177
south.yorkshire@bbc.co.uk



About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy