BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.

24 September 2014
South YorkshireSouth Yorkshire
GREEDY COW

BBC Homepage
»BBC Local
South Yorkshire
Things to do
People & Places
Nature
History
Religion & Ethics
Arts and Culture
BBC Introducing
TV & Radio

Sites near Sheffield

Bradford
Derby
Humberside
Leeds
Manchester
Nottingham

Related BBC Sites

England
 

Contact Us


November 2004
Blue Fin Seafood & Grill
Reader Review!
Reader Review!

Joanne thinks this new 'posh nosh' eaterie is brilliant. It's new too...

Helen doesn't agree though - saying it was short-staffed with average food...

SEE ALSO
Greedy Cow goes to market!

Greedy goes ghost hunting...

A trip inside Henderson's

SY beer tasting!

Greedy Cow FAQs

Write a review!

Grub reviews

Pub reviews
PRINT THIS PAGE
View a printable version of this page.
get in contact

5 moos - Joanne
0 moos - Helen

What's your name?
Joanne

Where is it?
Blue Fin Seafood & Grill
85 Junction Rd
Sheffield
S11 8XA

What's the number?
0114 266 0805

What's the grub like, then?
Superb. It was the first night and some customers thought the service wasn't up to scratch, we thought it was fab. Food was amazing, service was friendly and the delay wasn't much anyway.

What did you drink?
A brilliant white wine

What's the crowd like?
A real mix, from dressed up posh totty to jeans and jumpers customers

And the vibe?
Better than when it was the thai. Upmarket but very friendly and very smart

Anything else you'd like to say?
We'll be back and if the first night was any indication you'll need to book

Value for money?
£85 for 3 three course meals with an amazing bottle of wine. Good value for posh nosh


0 moos - Helen

What's your name?
Helen

What's the grub like, then?
Ok - and thats being too flattering - was expecting great things from all the hype, but thought the menu very average - we love seafood and trying out new dishes and were looking forward to this restaurant finally opening, but it really didn't live up to expectations.

Thai fishcake starters were dull and unexciting - it's not hard to do these well, and traditional posh fish and chips for over a tenner was very disappointing - and they were served with what was very obviously bottled tomato ketchup - purleese - come on!

What did you drink?
Wine - when it finally came! (see service) - from an unexciting and unimaginative list

What's the crowd like?
We were virtually the only ones there on a Friday night! Should that have told us something?

And the vibe?
Very Quiet! Even the staff were obvious by their absence!

Anything else you'd like to say?
The restaurant had been open a few weeks when we went, so the place had had time to settle in - or so we thought.

The service was appalling - it took half an hour to be shown to our table - even though the place was dead - and our drinks didn't actually appear until after we'd finished our starters and after asking several times - pretty basic stuff really.

The waitress was very apologetic that they were short staffed and the manager hadn't turned up that evening - which wasn't exactly a great start and didn't instill much confidence from the outset!

Value for money?
The bill came to over £200 for four of us - 3 courses with two bottles of wine and coffee - pretty expensive for pretty average food and below average service.

Your views

lofty
i went yesterday it was very poor. the worst man

ALEX SMITH
HAVE BEEN A FEW TIMES NOW AND IT IS FANTASTIC FOOD AND GREAT FRIENDLY SERVICE AT VALUE FOR MONEY PRICES. GOING AGAIN TONIGHT FOR A CHRISTMAS PARTY CAN NOT WAIT ! KEEP IT UP EXCELLENT !

Shorty
Went for the first time with some friends.The food was fabulous.Service excellent. As a fish restaurant it has to be number one in Sheffield and to my mind even outclasses the now defunct Slammers restaurant.The starters are to die for,the main courses were sublime and thew wine was not overpriced.The final touch was the owner/manager who seemed genuinely interested in our view of the evening.I shall return.

Linda
Having dined at this restaurant on numerous ocassions I cannot understand where some of the negative comments are coming from ( maybe a touch of the "green eyed monster" )The food is excellent and varied, always properly cooked and served, as any foodie knows seafood can be one of the most difficult foods to get right... so all credit to the chefs. As for price, with the current price of seafood I am amazed that they keep their prices at such a reasonable level.Obviously the Westside magazine agrees as they have awarded the Bluefin their "Newcomer Restaurant" of the year . Congrats to all involved... keep up the good work, from a very happy customer.

Kiki
Went for the £9.95 two course lunch - starter and main course with a large (and i mean LARGE!) glass of wine - yesterday. Excellent value for money and the tastiest fish and seafood I've eaten in ages - delicious! I saw a couple of people having puddings too and they looked really good. I'll definitely be going back to try out the a la carte menu for my birthday next month!

Hank Danger
Went on a saturday night. The food was smashing. had a great time, staff were fantastic and to top my night off they played Led Zeppelin on the stereo. Keep up the good work! 23/7/05

simon
I read your reviews and still gave it a chance..oh dear, soup tasted out of a tin and if I hadn't refused to eat my main course I would have been finished in 40 minutes £70 worse off...I would recommend it to anyone who knows a good food experince.

James Layton
Egregious

Jamie
After arriving in plenty of time for our 7pm table we were told there was no booking for us!! I got the impression it was our fault somehow, that somebody didn't put an entry in their diary. Therefore the meal seemed rushed. Having said that, the food was a high standard apart from the deep fried monkfish. This was spoiled due to the frying. The desserts were GORGEOUS! All in all a good dining experience, I recommend you go along and see for yourself, double check they have your booking recorded though!!

Bert
I have been to the Bluefin 4 times now and it just gets better and better, I went last week to learn that they had just launched a new evening menu which looks fantastic, I the thermidor and the fillet of seabass that was to die for ! I did also notice that they serve complimentary veg & potatoes which most fine dining restaurants charge. On writing this I have also just returned from lunch there, they are offering an incredible 2 course lunch with glass of fab wine for £8.95, for Eccleshall Rd and fantastic food it beggers believe. Long may this place reign, there are also more meat options on the new menu, I have not tried them yet but the steaks etc looked great. Keep up the good work.

Kirsten
I've been to Bluefin a couple of times now and it just keeps on getting better. Mouth-watering fish creations, sumptuous puddings, an excellent wine list and a great location. Keep up the good work! 24/03/05

Will
We went on a friday night. The food and service were faultless. The place was by no means full, but was busy enough so that we didn't feel that we were the only people there. About £70-80 for a three-course meal for two people was good value, considering the quality. Highly recommended to all except perhaps vegetarians. 22/03/05

Add your comments

What's your name?

Tell us what you thought about this review:

Thanks for your comments.
Disclaimer: The BBC may edit your comments and cannot guarantee that all e-mails will be published.

line
Top | Greedy Cow Index | Home

Also in Greedy Cow
Greedy Cow goes to market!

Greedy goes ghost hunting...

South Yorkshire beer tasting!

A trip inside Henderson's

Greedy Cow's FAQs

Meet the real Greedy Cows!


Also in Greedy Cow
Grub reviews A-Z

Grub reviews by cuisine

Pub and bar reviews A-Z

Pub and bar reviews by area

The Bull's Breakfasts


Write a Greedy Cow food review
Write a Greedy Cow pub review
Fun on a shoestring
Going Out
Contact Us
BBC South Yorkshire
54 Shoreham Street
Sheffield
S1 4RS
(+44) (0)114 273 1177
south.yorkshire@bbc.co.uk



About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy