BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.

24 September 2014
South YorkshireSouth Yorkshire
GREEDY COW

BBC Homepage
»BBC Local
South Yorkshire
Things to do
People & Places
Nature
History
Religion & Ethics
Arts and Culture
BBC Introducing
TV & Radio

Sites near Sheffield

Bradford
Derby
Humberside
Leeds
Manchester
Nottingham

Related BBC Sites

England
 

Contact Us


September, 2004
The Millstone
Reader Review!
Reader Review!
Karen and her family didn't have the best of experiences here - have you been? Tell us what you think...
SEE ALSO
Greedy Cow goes to market!

Greedy goes ghost hunting...

A trip inside Henderson's

SY beer tasting!

Greedy Cow FAQs

Write a review!

Grub reviews

Pub reviews
PRINT THIS PAGE
View a printable version of this page.
get in contact

1 moo

What's your name?
Karen Woodhouse

Where is it?
Westgate,
Tickhill,
Doncaster,
DN11 9NF

What's the number?
01302 745532

What's the grub like, then?
My husband & I took his parents to The Millstone, after they had previously been & enjoyed it. They, however, did not enjoy it this time. Neither did we.

We were sat in a dingy corner, rather close to the carvery station, which was unfortunate in itself, as I was to have full view of it throughout my meal.

We placed our order, three carveries & one from the menu.. Being a vegetarian, I browsed through the menu. There were a couple of choices, from the normal 'Vegetable bake-esque' to what sounded rather interesting, a 'Broccoli Rosti'. I ordered this & after some initial confusion, was told I could help myself to vegetables from the selection on the carvery.

We only waited about 6 minutes for my main course to be served, something which struck me as odd at the time, seeing as it was proudly proclaimed to be 'cooked to order'. The meal came & I was greeted by a dish of something indistinguishable, smothered in elastic, melted cheese.

We made our way over to the carvery, where my dining partners choose their meat. A choice of turkey, beef & what I presume to be pork, but it was impossible to tell for certain. The turkey was dry & stringy. The beef had been so over cooked that it crumbled when a knife came so much as near it & had to be put on the plates with a spoon. Nobody was brave enough to try the 'pork'.

The vegetable selection was disappointing. Frozen peas, soggy carrots & something pertaining to be parsnips (perhaps they were once, in a past life). The parsnips had been cooked at least two hours too long. They had not been peeled, simply chopped into huge hulking pieces & dried out in an oven. They were inedible and truly looked as though begging to be put out of their misery. The potatoes were from a catering pack of frozen, ready roasted-just reheat potatoes. The Yorkshire puddings were the same.

We returned to our table to try to eat our meal. I gave mine closer examination. My preconception of a rosti was a crispy, potato based dish, It was clearly exceedingly hot, as when I delved in with my fork, I was greeted by a huge eruption of steam. On closer inspection & after studying the menu again to see if I had been served the wrong dish, I came to the conclusion that it was supposedly a 'Broccoli Rosti'. That is, if a 'Broccoli Rosti' is frozen, packet veg, covered with cheap plastic cheese & micro waved to within an inch of its life.

Whilst trying to eat our meal, I was repeatedly put off by the sight of the restaurant manager, or one of the teenage 'chefs' using one tea towel to wipe crumbs of meat off the carving boards, swat flies that were hovering over the uncovered food or various other tasks for which it was not sanitary to use.

Throughout the meal we were dive bombed by many flies, so many in fact that we thought they must have an infestation, however, when we left, my husband noticed the kitchen windows flung wide open, all lights blazing & no blinds or curtains. This could well have been what invited so many of them into the dining room.

I would recommend you eat at The Millstone, only if you have absolutely no other option, & then, only if you were within minutes of death & wanted to be finished off quickly!

What did you drink?
Medium wine. I ordered dry.

What's the crowd like?
couples mainly

And the vibe?
not entirely relaxing, a bit forced.

Value for money?
No. £4.95 for Carvery £6.50 for menu option.

Your views

john i
Wow 2 bad reviews. eaten here for over a decade, its always packed you have to book a table days in advance now. that tells you quality and reputation of the place. 2/12/05. new owners hasnt decreased business a slight increase by the looks of it.

Stephen Brown
Carvery £4.95 NOT good value according to Karen...well at my local it's £6.95 and is nowhere near as plentiful or as well cooked...try living in the real world !!!

julianne morisso
absolute ruubish. i think a bit of overeacting is going on here. obviously couldn't think of anything better to do with their time so they wrote a crap review.

Dave B.
I've been a regular at The Millstone for over 2 years and would say that with very few exceptions the food is first class. The atmosphere has picked up too since the change in management earlier this year. Keep up the good work.

sharon
went their last week, truly horrible meal of fish sludge canelloni baked for 9 hours and served to hot to handle, commis chef sat in the bar smoking a fag with the uniform screwed up on another chair.

Steve
Under new management since May 2005. We used the upstairs function room, staff extremely helpful, food excellent and lots of it. Highly recommended.

Don Brasco
Very harsh review in my opinion, I have eaten here a few times and found the meal to be of suitable standard.

Parus
I regularly frequent the above to sample the carvery and for the price I have always found it excellent value for money. Yes I have had a problem with veg on the carvery it being a little repetitive wek in week out but I've never seen parsnips, or anything like them. On the whole it's a decent bit o' grub for the price.

Add your comments

What's your name?

Tell us what you thought about this review:

Thanks for your comments.
Disclaimer: The BBC may edit your comments and cannot guarantee that all e-mails will be published.

line
Top | Greedy Cow Index | Home

Also in Greedy Cow
Greedy Cow goes to market!

Greedy goes ghost hunting...

South Yorkshire beer tasting!

A trip inside Henderson's

Greedy Cow's FAQs

Meet the real Greedy Cows!


Also in Greedy Cow
Grub reviews A-Z

Grub reviews by cuisine

Pub and bar reviews A-Z

Pub and bar reviews by area

The Bull's Breakfasts


Write a Greedy Cow food review
Write a Greedy Cow pub review
Fun on a shoestring
Going Out
Contact Us
BBC South Yorkshire
54 Shoreham Street
Sheffield
S1 4RS
(+44) (0)114 273 1177
south.yorkshire@bbc.co.uk



About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy