Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education



Front Page

World

UK

UK Politics

Business

Sci/Tech

Health

Education

Sport

Entertainment

Talking Point

In Depth

On Air

Archive
Feedback
Low Graphics
Help

Saturday, August 28, 1999 Published at 12:29 GMT 13:29 UK


UK: Wales

Abandoned calves are destroyed

The end of subsidies has rendered calves worthless, farmers say.

RSPCA officials have put down all 20 of the calves left at phone boxes and other points across west Wales over the past week by farmers protesting at the crisis in the agriculture industry.

An RSPCA spokesman said they had no choice following what they believed was unnecessary and irresponsible action by the farmers.

The animal welfare charity said it had no choice about putting the animals down as they were not tagged.

This made it impossible to trace their histories to check if they were from BSE-free herds and the RSPCA was informed it was illegal either to keep them or to move them.

RSPCA officer Huw Evans said: "By law, we are not allowed to move them because we cannot prove that they do not have BSE and may contaminate other animals.

"We would love to have homes found for them but we are not allowed to."


RSPCA spokesman Huw Evans dubbed the action 'a reckless publicity stunt'
The RSPCA has warned that if it finds the farmers responsible for abandoning the animals, they will be prosecuted. It has condemned the dumping as a "reckless publicity stunt".

The calves' destruction came the day after Welsh Agriculture Secretary Christine Gwyther met her Westminster counterpart to press for the extension of a vital calf compensation scheme for farmers.

But Agriculture Minister Nick Brown offered no extra cash to Welsh beef farmers and Ms Gwyther is now expected to raise the matter in a meeting next week with Assembly First Secretary Alun Michael.

The cattle industry in Wales has been in crisis since the government scrapped a scheme which guaranteed farmers a minimum price for bull calves, which could not be sold abroad due to the beef export ban.


BBC Wales's Sian Parry-Hughes speaks to MEP Robert Sturdy
MEP Robert Sturdy, Conservative agriculture spokesman in Europe, said it was "about time" questions were asked about the future of the British farming industry.

"If we do want it, we have to pay for it," he said.

The plight of farmers had been made difficult by shifts right across the livestock market.

"There is no doubt, whenever you interfere with a market, farmers move. The trouble for livestock farmers is that they have very little room to manoeuvre."

Many Welsh farmers have found it impossible to sell their calves since the collapse of the export trade.

A total of 17 were dumped in public places in order to draw attention to the industry's plight.


The BBC's Wyre Davies reports: "It costs more to process them through market than they're worth"
On Wednesday, the Farmers' Union of Wales, the National Farmers' Union and the Country Landowners' Association met Ms Gwyther to call for emergency discussions between farming organisations and government throughout the UK.

Ms Gwyther pledged to support farmers in the battle to restore the compensation scheme for bull calves.

"I have assured farmers' leaders that I will be giving further thought to their suggestions," said Ms Gwyther.

"In principle, I support these ideas, but there are financial and legal problems that would have to be overcome before they could be brought in.


[ image: Christine Gwyther held talks with farmers' leaders]
Christine Gwyther held talks with farmers' leaders
"Early next week, I will be meeting First Secretary Alun Michael and it would not be sensible to make any decisions on today's proposals before then."

However, Bob Parry, leader of the FUW, said after the meeting that dealing with the Assembly was useless and that farmers needed to go to a higher level of government.


BBC Wales's Jon Manel joins the RSPCA in rescuing an abandoned calf
Farmers want the veal trade to the continent to reopen or the £40-per-calf compensation scheme to be reintroduced.

Bull calves sold for as little as 50 pence each at Cardigan mart in west Wales on Monday.

Two calves offered to Ms Gwyther by the Farmers' Union of Wales as a protest at the Pembrokeshire Show last week have since been killed and fed to hunting dogs at a kennel in west Wales.



Advanced options | Search tips




Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©



Relevant Stories

19 Aug 99 | Wales
Politicians back demand for Assembly recall

17 Aug 99 | Wales
Gwyther refuses 'gift' from farmers

01 Aug 99 | Wales
Celebrations as beef ban lifted

15 Jul 99 | Special Report
Beef ban report secrecy defended





Internet Links


National Assembly for Wales

Meat and Livestock Commission

National Farmers' Union

Dyfed-Powys Police

RSPCA

Farmers' Union of Wales


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.




In this section

Labour explores Assembly election wounds

Delays hit coach crash compensation

Ex-headmaster guilty of more sex charges

Museum in pay-off probe

Euro row over "Welsh" money rebate

Germans challenge Cardiff for Tyson fight

Ticket chief resigns after World Cup fiasco

Quick-thinking driver foils 'carjacker'

Spring clean for river

Roman remains may halt rugby centre plan

Olympic rider Sir Harry is mourned

The Welsh Week at Westminster

Hanged farmer had been cautioned

Children take over the Assembly

Assembly security review follows pupil's 'threat'

Opposition parties criticise Health Secretary

Welsh airline is launched

Anglesey power plan may bring 1,500 jobs

Former paratroopers recruited drugs courier

Star's cyber-fans help Welsh charity

Labour election inquest blames party rifts

New factory creates 500 jobs

Bassey will go world wide on the web

French boycott gathers pace

Villagers fume at delay over sewage problem

Pensioner leaves fortune to birds

MP demands return of Glyndwr letter